A charity website redesign is a chance to fix what isn’t working: a donation journey that loses people, pages nobody can find, a site your team is nervous to edit. It’s also a project that can go wrong in expensive ways if you skip the groundwork. This guide takes you from the first conversation to the month after launch, with a brief template you can copy.
The short version
- Start with evidence. Find out what’s working now before you decide what to change.
- Decide whether you need a redesign or a refresh. Not every tired website needs rebuilding.
- Write a short brief. Two pages is enough, and the template below covers what agencies need.
- Protect what you’ve built. Keep your best pages and redirect every old address, or you’ll lose search traffic.
- Start on content early. It is usually the slowest part of the whole project.
Step 1: Find out what’s working and what isn’t
Before anyone opens a design tool, gather the evidence. It will shape the brief, settle internal debates and give you a baseline to measure the new site against.
- Analytics: your most visited pages, the pages people arrive on, how many visitors start and finish a donation, and the split between phone and desktop.
- Google Search Console: the searches and pages that bring people to you. These are the pages to protect.
- People: ask the staff who edit the site what frustrates them, and ask a handful of supporters and service users to complete a simple task while you watch.
- Accessibility: run an automated checker, then try the main journeys using only a keyboard. It takes ten minutes and usually tells you a lot.
- Technical health: how old is the site, who maintains it, and is it up to date? Our free WordPress version checker is a quick first look.
It also helps to know how you compare. Our crawl of UK charity websites found that only 37.2% of the 55,300 sites that answered show a visible way to donate online. If yours is one of the others, that’s your first priority. See what we found.
Step 2: Decide whether you need a redesign or a refresh
| A refresh is probably enough if | You probably need a redesign if |
|---|---|
| The platform is modern and kept up to date | The site is on an old or unsupported platform, or nobody can update it safely |
| Your team can edit pages comfortably | Every change needs a developer or a support ticket |
| The main problems are content and navigation | The site isn’t accessible and can’t be fixed without rebuilding |
| Donations work, but the page could be clearer | Donations send people away, break on mobile or lose Gift Aid |
| Your brand is broadly the same | You’ve rebranded, merged or changed what you do |
Step 3: Get your organisation behind it
- Name one decision-maker with the time and authority to approve things between meetings.
- Agree what trustees need to see, and when. Plan sign-off points around board meeting dates.
- Budget for the whole life of the site, not just the build. Running costs are usually £1,500 to £3,000 a year. Our guide to charity website costs breaks it down.
- Look for funding. Some grants will pay for a website, especially unrestricted or core-cost funding. Our Funding Finder lists them.
- Set a realistic timeline. Most redesigns take eight to twelve weeks, and completely bespoke builds up to sixteen. Our guide to how long a charity website takes explains why.
Step 4: Write a brief (template)
Copy these headings into a document and write a few lines under each. Agencies don’t need a fifty-page specification. They need to understand your charity and what the site must do.
| Section | What to include |
|---|---|
| 1. About us | What you do, who for, where, and roughly how big you are. One paragraph. |
| 2. Why now | What isn’t working about the current site, with the evidence from step 1. |
| 3. Who the site is for | Your audiences in order of priority, such as people seeking support, donors, volunteers and funders. |
| 4. What the site must do | The three to five jobs that matter most, written so you could measure them. “Make it easier to donate monthly” rather than “look modern”. |
| 5. What we have now | Platform, number of pages, hosting, who built it and what it connects to. |
| 6. Must-haves | WCAG 2.2 AA accessibility, donations with Gift Aid, CRM connection, staff editing, data protection, anything else you cannot do without. |
| 7. Content | Who will write new copy, how much needs moving across and whether you need photography. |
| 8. Budget and timeline | A budget range, including running costs, and any dates that cannot move. |
| 9. How we will choose | Your criteria, the process and the dates for proposals, interviews and a decision. |
| 10. Contacts | Who to send questions to, and by when. |
Step 5: Choose your agency
Send the brief to three agencies, ask each the same questions and compare like with like. Our guide to choosing a charity web design agency has twelve questions to ask and the red flags to watch for.
Step 6: Start on content early
- Audit what you have. List every page and decide: keep, rewrite, merge or delete. Most charity sites can lose a third of their pages without anyone missing them.
- Give each section an owner who writes or approves it, with a deadline.
- Write for the people you serve, in plain English, with the most important information first.
- Gather photos with consent, especially of the people you support, and record what each person agreed to.
Step 7: Protect your search rankings
This is the step charities most often regret skipping. Every page address on your old site that people or search engines know about needs to point to the right page on the new one.
- List every old page address, using your sitemap, Search Console and a crawl of the current site.
- Map each old address to its new equivalent, and keep the addresses of your best-performing pages the same where you can.
- Set up permanent (301) redirects for everything that moves, and update internal links so they point straight to the new pages.
- Submit the new sitemap in Search Console on launch day, then check for errors every week for the first month.
We learned this the hard way on our own website. A handful of old service pages that we hadn’t redirected dropped out of Google entirely until we fixed them.
Step 8: Launch, and the first thirty days
- Test every form and make a real donation, then refund it. Check the receipt and the Gift Aid declaration arrive where they should.
- Check analytics and cookie consent are working, so you can measure the new site from day one.
- Publish an accessibility statement and an up-to-date privacy policy.
- Watch Search Console for pages that can’t be found, and fix them quickly.
- Train the people who will edit the site, and agree who looks after updates and security from now on.
Mistakes we see
- Designing for the board rather than the people who use the site.
- Launching without redirects from the old site.
- Copying every old page across unchanged.
- Leaving the donation journey until the end of the project.
- Budgeting for the build but not the years of running costs after it.
How we can help
We plan and build charity websites on WordPress, with on-site donations, WCAG 2.2 AA accessibility and a redirect plan for every old page. See how we approach charity web design, or book a discovery call and bring your brief.
Questions charities ask
How often should a charity redesign its website?
There’s no set rule. A well-built site can last five years or more with regular updates. Redesign when it stops doing its job: when donations, accessibility, editing or security become a problem.
Will a redesign hurt our Google rankings?
It can, if old page addresses are not redirected or good content is thrown away. With a proper redirect plan, rankings usually hold, and often improve once the new site is faster and clearer.
Can we keep our domain name?
Yes, and in most cases you should. Your domain carries years of links and search history. Make sure it’s registered in your charity’s name, not your old agency’s.
Should we change platform when we redesign?
Only if the current one is holding you back. Our guide to choosing a charity website platform compares the options.

